The Biggest Mistakes that Pierce County Sellers Make

by Don & Susie Karstedt

Selling your home can feel overwhelming—especially when everyone has an opinion. There’s a lot of information out there, and not all of it is true.

If you're planning to sell in Pierce County, it helps to know what’s fact and what’s just a popular myth. At Rethinking Real Estate, we’re here to clear things up and help you make smarter decisions with confidence.


Myth #1: You Should Price High to Leave Room for Negotiation

It’s a common idea: price your home high so you have room to come down later.

Reality:
Overpricing can hurt more than it helps. Most buyers today are well-informed and won’t even look at homes that seem overpriced. A listing that sits too long can go stale, forcing price drops later.

A better approach:
Price your home competitively from the start, based on a current market analysis. It will attract more serious buyers—and in some cases, lead to multiple offers.


Myth #2: Spring Is Always the Best Time to Sell

Spring is known as a busy season in real estate, but that doesn’t mean it’s the only time to list.

Reality:
Every season has its advantages. Selling in winter in Pierce County can mean:

  • Less competition from other listings

  • More serious, motivated buyers

  • Faster timelines for inspections and financing

Bottom line: Don’t wait for the “perfect” season. With the right strategy, homes sell year-round.


Myth #3: You Don’t Need a Real Estate Agent in the Age of the Internet

With all the online tools available, it might seem like you can manage the sale on your own.

Reality:
Online platforms are useful—but they don’t replace the expertise and protection a good agent brings.

Here’s what a seasoned agent offers:

  • Local market insights

  • Smart pricing strategies

  • Skilled negotiation

  • Help with contracts and legal details

  • A trusted network (inspectors, mortgage pros, contractors, etc.)

The right agent keeps your sale on track and your investment protected.


Myth #4: Renovating Always Boosts the Sale Price

Thinking about a kitchen remodel or new floors before listing?

Reality:
Not every renovation pays off. Some updates cost more than they return. Focus on projects that improve the home’s presentation without breaking the bank.

Try this instead:

  • Touch up paint

  • Fix minor repairs

  • Improve lighting and curb appeal

Ask your agent which upgrades are worth it before you spend the money.


Myth #5: You Can’t Sell in a Buyer’s Market

Many sellers assume it’s better to wait if the market favors buyers.

Reality:
Homes still sell in a buyer’s market—you just need to be strategic.

Key tips:

  • Set a realistic asking price

  • Invest in professional photography

  • Use virtual tours and strong marketing

  • Stage the home to show its full potential

With the right marketing, your home can stand out—even with more competition.


Myth #6: Home Inspections Are Only for Older Homes

If your home is newer or updated, do you really need an inspection?

Reality:
Yes. Inspections aren’t just for old houses. Every home, no matter the age, can have hidden issues.

Benefits of a pre-listing inspection:

  • Identify and fix problems before buyers see them

  • Build trust with buyers

  • Reduce the chance of surprises during closing


Selling in Pierce County? Keep These Truths in Mind

The real estate market in Washington—including right here in Pierce County—is always changing. Whether you’re selling now or planning ahead, having the right information (and the right team) makes all the difference.

Don’t let myths steer you in the wrong direction.


Ready to Sell with Confidence?

Rethinking Real Estate is here to help you:

  • Understand the market

  • Make smart decisions

  • Navigate the process from start to finish

📞 Contact us today for expert advice and personalized service. Let’s make sure your next move is the right one.

 

Prefer a different format?
You can also:

Share on Social Media

agent-avatar

If you haven't subscribed to our newsletter, you're missing out on great stories like the one above that could be coming right to your inbox every few weeks.

Please use the form to request a subscription.

GET MORE INFORMATION

Name
Phone*
Message